Skip to content

AI writing is not improving no matter how I prompt

Situation

  • You have tried many different prompts with the same AI tool
  • Each output looks different, but none is clearly better
  • You keep tweaking instructions, examples, or constraints
  • Improvements feel random rather than directional
  • You are unsure whether the problem is the prompt or the task itself

This situation appears when prompting replaces problem definition.

Verdict

VERDICT: STOP

Continuing to tweak prompts will not reliably improve the output. The issue is not prompt precision, but task clarity.

Why this verdict

  • The AI is responding correctly to unclear or unstable instructions
  • Prompt changes are compensating for an undefined goal
  • Without a fixed success criterion, variation is mistaken for progress

Prompting cannot resolve ambiguity it is given.

What happens if you continue

  • You will cycle through many prompt versions without convergence
  • Output quality will fluctuate unpredictably
  • Time will be spent refining instructions instead of the task

This often leads to frustration and diminishing returns.

A safer next step

Stop adjusting prompts.

Clarify the task outside the AI: - Define exactly what a successful result looks like - Decide what the output is for and who it is for - Reduce the task to a single, stable objective

Once the task is clear, prompting becomes simpler and more effective.